What’s the Cost of a Bad Hire?

The challenge in determining the cost of a bad hire lies in the varying opinions and methods available. Some estimates suggest the cost could be as high as 50–75% of that person’s salary. Certain studies indicate that some positions may cost anywhere from 1 to 1.5 times the annual salary, especially for higher-level positions.

Potential Cost of a Bad Hire in Sales

• Compensation: $60,000 annually
• Benefits: $5,500 annually
• Hiring Costs: $1,500 (including manager interview time, advertising, testing, and interview entertainment)
• Equipment: $600 annually (e.g., cell phone, laptop)
• Training Costs: $5,000 minimum for the first year
• Lost Productivity: $3,500 (management's time spent addressing issues caused by the bad hire)
• Total Annual Cost: $76,100

If this individual remains employed for a minimum of six months, the cost to the agency would be $38,050. Given that the average agency’s success rate in hiring salespeople is only 20–25%, the cost of keeping a bad hire continues to accumulate. Many agencies retain poor hires for 12 to 18 months, further increasing expenses.

Having a well-structured hiring and onboarding process won’t eliminate every bad hire, but it can significantly improve hiring success rates. Imagine achieving an 80% success rate—it’s possible, but it requires a strong commitment, something many agencies fail to prioritize. If you understand the financial impact of a bad hire, you will likely be motivated to implement a better hiring process.

The 4 Pillars of a Good Hiring Process

1. Clearly Defined Role

Without clarity, it’s impossible to determine whether a candidate is the right fit. To target the ideal hire, you must first define the role. Key elements of an Ideal New Hire Profile include:

• Purpose of the Role: Write a concise, objective paragraph defining the position.
• Key Results: Identify 4–5 measurable results required for success.
• Job Values: Determine what a candidate must value to thrive in the role (e.g., fast-paced multitasking vs. structured, linear tasks).
• Skills and Abilities: Assess past experiences, training, and skills that indicate a candidate’s ability to succeed. Keep in mind that no candidate is perfect—everyone has strengths and weaknesses.
• Culture Fit: Cultural alignment is crucial. If a candidate isn’t a good cultural fit, they may leave quickly or cause disruptions, negatively impacting the organization.

2. Hire from Want, Not Need

Hiring out of desperation often leads to rushed decisions and poor hires. To break this cycle, agencies must shift toward hiring from want instead of need by implementing the following:

• Ongoing Talent Pipeline: The best organizations proactively recruit, even when there are no immediate openings. In smaller agencies, this responsibility may fall on key leaders, not just HR.
• Consistent Focus: Many companies treat hiring as a priority for only 30–60 days before losing momentum. To make recruitment an ongoing part of the organization’s culture, set goals, track progress, and hold team members accountable.

3. Clear and Consistent Process

Many companies fail to hire top talent due to inconsistent interview processes. To improve hiring effectiveness, organizations must:

• Use the same interview process for a given role.
• Ensure the same interviewers assess all candidates for a particular position.
• Ask the same structured interview questions.
• Use standardized assessments for every candidate.
• Follow a defined decision-making framework.

4. Formalized Onboarding Process

Gallup research indicates that employee engagement drops after 60 days—a sign that most companies fail at onboarding. This is particularly true in sales, where employees often start slowly. A structured onboarding process should include:

• Organizational Values: New hires need to understand the company’s core values to make informed decisions.
• Cultural Alignment: Clarify the company’s beliefs and expected behaviors to integrate new employees effectively.
• Training & Skill Development: Provide a clear roadmap for how employees will develop their abilities.
• Resources for Growth: Ensure new hires know where to find knowledge, training, and support to increase productivity.
• Defined Performance Expectations: Setting clear success metrics allows both the employee and employer to track progress and make course corrections if necessary.

"Attracting and retaining top talent is critical to our business." — Gregg Goodmanson

Summary

The impact of hiring on a company’s bottom line is undeniable. Top-performing organizations prioritize hiring as an ongoing strategic initiative. Achieving better hiring results requires a strong leadership commitment to structured processes. By doing so, your agency can enhance performance and increase profitability.

‍

by Gregg Goodmanson